Margaret Ellis
Please note that the decision can take up to 5 working days to be uploaded onto the HCPTS website. Please contact one of our Hearings Team Managers via tsteam@hcpts-uk.org or +44 (0)808 164 3084 if you require any further information.
Allegation
As a registered Occupational Therapist [OT02230]:
1. On or around 13 September 2022, you sent an email to one or more third party individuals disclosing confidential information relating to Child A and/or their family.
2. The matters set out in Particular 1 amount to misconduct.
3. By reason of the matters set out above, your fitness to practise is impaired by reason of misconduct.
Finding
Preliminary Matters
Potential Conflict of Interest
1. At the outset of the hearing Professor McClure declared that she was aware of the Registrant from her time as Chair of the Royal College of Occupational Therapists between 2015 and 2019. She stated that the Registrant had been Chair of the College of Occupational Therapists between 1987 and 1989, and that following her appointment in 2015, she had received a letter from the Registrant which she was required to respond to. She did not recall the specific details of the letter and stated that she only recalled the interaction upon a detailed reading of the case papers. Professor McClure further declared that she had been introduced to the Registrant in passing at an event. Professor McClure indicated that she had no other professional or personal involvement with the Registrant and considered that she was able to act impartially in dealing with the Registrant’s case.
2. Ms Manning-Rees on behalf of the HCPC, after clarifying the nature of the ‘relationship’, had no objections to Professor McClure continuing to sit on the Panel.
3. The Panel received and accepted the advice of the Legal Assessor who set out the test established by the case of Porter v Magill [2001] UKHL 67.
4. The Panel noted that there had been historic contact on a limited ‘arms-length’ basis, and that there was no previous or current professional or personal relationship between Professor McClure and the Registrant. It considered that Professor McClure had no personal interest in the outcome of this hearing.
5. The Panel concluded that the involvement of the Registrant Panel Member would not cause any prejudice to the Registrant, that Professor McClure was able to conduct herself professionally, and that the Registrant would receive a fair and impartial hearing.
Service
6. The Notice of Hearing was sent to the Registrant, by email to her registered email address, and by post, on 17 August 2026 informing her that there would be a review of the Suspension Order on 11 November 2026. An email delivery notification has been provided.
7. The Practice Note requires proof of sending rather than proof of receipt to effect good service. It is the responsibility of the Registrant to keep her contact details up to date with the HCPC.
8. The Panel was satisfied that service had been effected in accordance with the Procedure Rules and Practice Note on Service of Documents.
Proceeding in absence
9. The Panel considered whether it was appropriate and fair to conduct the hearing in the absence of the Registrant. The Panel had regard to the representations made by Ms Manning-Rees on behalf of the HCPC.
10. The Panel considered the HCPTS Practice Note on ‘Proceeding in the Absence of the Registrant’ and accepted the advice of the Legal Assessor. The Panel was mindful that today’s hearing was a mandatory review of the Suspension Order which is due to expire on 18 December 2026.
11. The Panel was aware of the need to exercise its discretion to proceed in the Registrant’s absence with the utmost care and caution. The Panel was referred to the case of GMC v Adeogba and Visvardis [2016] EWCA Civ 162 which reminded the Panel that its primary objective is the protection of the public and the public interest and that the “fair, economical, expeditious and efficient disposal of allegations made against medical practitioners is of very real importance”. In that regard, the case made clear that, “where there is good reason not to proceed, the case should be adjourned; where there is not, however, it is only right that it should proceed”.
12. The Panel noted that the Notice of Hearing dated 17 August 2026 gave the Registrant the opportunity to attend, submit any written representations or seek an adjournment.
13. The Panel had sight of a number of emails sent to the Registrant and her responses and was satisfied that all reasonable steps had been taken to engage the Registrant in the hearing. The Panel noted in an email from the Registrant dated 09 November 2026 that she stated she would not be attending the hearing.
14. In all the circumstances the Panel decided that it was fair and in the interests of justice to proceed with the hearing in the absence of the Registrant as it concluded that she had voluntarily absented herself and that no useful purpose would be served by an adjournment in that it would be unlikely to secure the Registrant’s attendance. The Panel noted that the Registrant had not engaged in the previous hearing.
15. The Panel was mindful of the need to proceed expeditiously where it was appropriate to do so. The Panel decided that there was a strong public interest in proceeding in the absence of the Registrant as the Suspension Order was due to expire on 18 December 2026. It considered that the public interest in proceeding outweighed any prejudice to the Registrant.
Privacy Application
16. Ms Manning-Rees on behalf of the HCPC did not invite the Panel to hear the matter partly in private as she did not intend referring to any matters which should not be in the public domain.
Background
17. The Registrant is a HCPC registered Occupational Therapist.
18. On 13 September 2022, the HCPC received a referral from a member of the public, Person A. Person A is the father of Child A and he stated that the Registrant was engaged by Suffolk County Council to provide occupational therapy services to Child A.
19. Person A alleged that the Registrant sent an email to various parties on 13 September 2022 containing a large amount of confidential information regarding Child A and their family. The email was addressed to the Headteacher of School B, at which Child A had started being educated in September 2022. However, the email was also copied to various other parties. These included the Headteacher of Child A’s previous school, a Special Educational Needs and Disability (SEND) officer, a solicitor, and the Lead of Suffolk County Council.
20. It was alleged that the email sent by the Registrant contained information concerning Child A’s occupational therapy, personal needs, and details of other multidisciplinary teams concerned in Child A’s care. Person A stated that the Registrant was no longer involved in providing Child A’s care and that he had not given consent for the information to be disclosed. At the time of the email, Child A was six years old.
21. The HCPC relied on the evidence of two witnesses called to give oral evidence:
• Person A;
• Witness 1, who was at the time the Deputy Headteacher at School B.
22. The substantive hearing of the Allegation took place between 28 May and 01 May 2025. That panel found the factual particulars proven amounted to misconduct and that the Registrant’s fitness to practise was impaired. That panel imposed a 9-month Suspension Order and an 18-month Interim Suspension Order to cover the appeal period.
23. The Registrant appealed the decision and was unsuccessful. The Suspension Order commenced on the conclusion of the appeal proceedings and is due to expire on 18 December 2026.
24. That panel at the substantive hearing indicated that a future panel would be assisted by the following:-
• Written reflections on the Panel’s findings of impairment set out above, demonstrating the Registrant’s insight, linking to professional standards, and the effects on service users, the profession, and the wider public;
• Evidence of any CPD, training, or other learning in relation to the Panel’s findings and demonstrating that the Registrant has kept her knowledge and skills up to date.
• Any relevant references and/or testimonials.
• Any other material the Registrant considers relevant.
25. This is a mandatory review of the Order.
Submissions
26. Ms Manning-Rees gave information to the Panel regarding the background to the Allegation which was found proved. She stated that the Registrant had disclosed confidential information to third parties which she was not authorised to disclose, and that some of the information was highly sensitive.
27. Ms Manning-Rees submitted that the Registrant had not engaged with the HCPC and that her fitness to practise continues to be impaired. It was identified that whilst the previous panel had found the conduct to be remediable, there was no evidence from the Registrant that she had undertaken the actions suggested to demonstrate that there was no longer a risk of repetition.
28. It was submitted that the Registrant’s failure to acknowledge the authority of the HCPC raises the risk profile and the risk of repetition.
29. The Panel was invited to extend the Suspension Order for a period of 6 months to give the Registrant a further opportunity to engage and undertake remediation.
30. The Panel did not receive any submissions or representations by or on behalf of the Registrant.
Legal Assessor’s Advice
31. The Legal Assessor advised that this was a Review under Article 30(1) of the Health Professions Order 2001, and the Panel was referred to the HCPTS Practice Notes on ‘Review of Article 30 Sanction Orders’, ‘Fitness to Practise Impairment’ and the ‘Sanctions Policy’. The Panel was reminded that Article 30(1) of the Health Professions Order 2001 provides the Panel with a power to:
- extend, or further extend the period for which the order has effect;
- make an order which could have been made when the order being reviewed was made;
- replace a suspension order with a conditions of practice order; or
- allow the order to lapse on expiry.
32. Any order made following an Article 30(1) review only takes effect from the date on which the order under review expires, so the Registrant must continue to comply with the expiring order until then.
33. The Panel was reminded that the review process is not a mechanism for appealing against or ‘going behind’ the original finding that the Registrant’s fitness to practice is impaired. The purpose of the review is to consider:-
• Whether the Registrant’s fitness to practise remains impaired; and
• If so, whether the existing order or another order needs to be in place to protect the public.
34. The key issue which needs to be addressed is what, if anything, has changed since the current order was imposed. The factors to be taken into account include:
• the steps which the Registrant has taken to address any specific failings or other issues identified in the previous decision;
• the degree of insight shown and whether this has changed;
• the steps which the Registrant has taken to maintain or improve their professional knowledge and skills; and
• whether any other fitness to practice issues have arisen.
35. The reviewing Panel’s task “is to consider whether all the concerns raised in the original finding of impairment...[have] been sufficiently addressed”. Abrahaem v GMC [2008] EWHC 183 (Admin). There is a ‘persuasive burden’ on the Registrant to demonstrate at a review hearing that she has fully acknowledged the deficiencies which led to the original finding and has addressed that impairment sufficiently “through insight, application, education, supervision or other achievement...”.
36. The decision reached must be proportionate, striking a fair balance between interfering with the Registrant’s ability to practise and the overarching objective of public protection.
37. In making proportionate decisions on sanction, the Panel must strike a balance between the competing interests of the Registrant and the HCPC’s overriding objective to protect the public. Therefore, its decision should deal with the concerns raised, but be fair, just and reasonable. Sanctions are not intended to be punitive. The Panel should only take the minimum action necessary to ensure the public is protected. This means considering the least restrictive sanction available to it first and only moving on to a more restrictive sanction if it is necessary to protect the public.
Decision on Impairment
38. In reaching its’ decision today the Panel considered all the information before it. The Panel first considered whether the Registrant’s fitness to practise remains impaired. The Panel was aware that the persuasive burden is upon the Registrant to demonstrate that her fitness to practise is no longer impaired. The Panel had regard to the decision of the substantive panel. However, it comprehensively reviewed the matter and exercised its own judgment in reaching its’ decision.
39. The Panel had regard to the HCPTS Practice Notes ‘Review of Article 30 Sanction Orders’ and ‘Fitness to Practice Impairment’ and accepted the advice of the Legal Assessor. The Panel had sight of the HCPC bundle of 51 pages, and the bundle of 4 pages containing an email from the Registrant dated 09 November 2026.
40. The Panel first of all considered whether the Registrant’s fitness to practise was currently impaired looking at both the personal component and the public component. The Panel acknowledged the comments of the panel who heard the substantive matter.
41. The Panel considered the case of CHRE v NMC and Grant [2011] EWHC 927 (Admin) which adopted and clarified the test for impairment of fitness to practise, which was formulated by Dame Janet Smith in the Fifth Shipman Inquiry with reference to the following questions:-
a. Has the Registrant acted in the past (or is liable to act in the future) in a way that puts patients at unwarranted risk of harm.
b. Has the Registrant brought (or is liable to bring) the profession into disrepute.
c. Has the Registrant breached (or is liable to breach) one of the fundamental tenets of the profession.
d. Has the Registrant acted dishonestly.
42. The Panel took account of the findings of the previous panel and considered that limbs a, b and c were engaged in this case. There was a clear risk of emotional and psychological harm being caused to a vulnerable child and their family. The unauthorised disclosure of personal information is a matter which would bring the profession into disrepute. Members of the public are entitled to expect that the professionals trusted with their personal data respect that data and do not disclose it without authority to do so. The Registrant is under a duty to protect the public and manage the risks of harm. Further, the Registrant’s apparent hostility and lack of respect for the HCPC as a professional regulator is something which brings the profession into disrepute.
43. The Panel also noted the substantive hearing panel’s conclusions that the Registrant’s actions had breached fundamental tenets of the profession, to promote and protect the interests of service users, and a number of the Standards of Conduct, Performance and Ethics were found to be engaged.
44. The Panel noted paragraph 83 of the substantive decision which states:-
‘The Panel found, however, that it had no evidence from the Registrant that she had appropriately reflected, trained, or gained any insight into the issues. There was no information on how the Registrant had conducted herself since the events in question, and no testimonials or references as to her general character. The Registrant had not engaged with the hearing and no information was provided on her behalf from which the Panel might consider that she had developed her practice or insight since she had sent the email in question. Therefore, the Panel concluded that there remains a risk of repetition of past misconduct and it could not say the misconduct was “highly unlikely” to be repeated’.
45. Due to the lack of engagement of the Registrant and her failure to attend the review hearing, the Panel concluded that the Registrant had failed to discharge the persuasive burden to demonstrate that she had fully acknowledged the deficiencies which led to the original finding and has addressed that impairment sufficiently “through insight, application, education, supervision or other achievement...”. The Registrant provided nothing to suggest that she has taken steps to address the failings.
46. The Panel considered that the issues which led to the finding of impairment were possible to remediate. It was of the view that remedial action had not been taken due to the Registrant’s lack of engagement.
47. The Panel had no information as to whether the Registrant wished to return to practice in the future, or whether there were issues which were impacting upon the ability of the Registrant to undertake reflections, remediation or develop insight into her actions. If there was anything preventing the Registrant from fully engaging, she had not provided evidence of this to the HCPC.
48. In considering the risk of repetition, the Panel was aware that the Registrant had failed to undertake the reflections, remediation and Continuing Professional Development (CPD) recommended by the previous panel. The Registrant has not addressed the original concerns, and the Panel concluded that due to the lack of insight, remediation and engagement there was a high risk of repetition.
49. In the absence of any evidence to suggest that the Registrant has remediated, there remains a risk of harm to the public.
50. The Panel determined that on the personal component the Registrant’s fitness to practise remains impaired.
51. The Panel went on to consider the public component. Due to the identified risk of repetition and there being little evidence of fully developed insight or remediation, there inevitably remains a risk to the public and there is a need to protect the public from risk of harm.
52. The Panel was concerned that the Registrant had breached the Standards of Conduct, Performance and Ethics and had shown a lack of respect for the authority of her regulator. It appeared that the Registrant continued to deny the Allegation and did not acknowledge the need for her to take remedial action. There had been a significant departure from the Standards expected of a registered OT and, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, the Panel was concerned that the Registrant may not be candid should things go wrong, and would not adhere to the Standards of Conduct, Performance and Ethics, which would place service users at risk of harm.
53. In considering the public component the Panel found that members of the public would be concerned, and would not have confidence in the profession, or in the regulator, if the Registrant was permitted to return to unrestricted practice at present. Accordingly, the Panel found that the Registrant’s fitness to practise was impaired on the public component also.
54. The Panel concluded that the Registrant’s fitness to practise was currently impaired on both the personal and the public component and it must go on to consider the issue of the appropriate sanction to address the concerns identified.
Decision on Sanction
55. The Panel looked at the Sanctions Policy considering the least restrictive sanction available to them first and only moving on to a more restrictive sanction if it was necessary to protect the public. The Panel was aware that the sanction is not a punishment for the Registrant but that it may have a punitive effect.
56. The Panel did not seek to repeat the aggravating and mitigating features identified by the panel following the substantive hearing.
57. The Panel first considered mediation or taking no action and determined that these were not appropriate due to the serious nature of the concerns and the risk of repetition identified. The Panel considered that the risks could not be managed through mediation or taking no action. In addition, these outcomes would not satisfy public confidence in the profession or the regulatory process.
58. The Panel was satisfied that it was appropriate to impose a sanction.
59. The Panel then considered whether a caution order would be appropriate and had regard to paragraphs 146-151 of the Sanctions Policy. The Panel concluded that the Allegation found proved was serious. The Registrant has not demonstrated any steps to address the concerns or expressed insight into her conduct since the substantive hearing, and the Panel found that there was a risk of repetition, and as a consequence of that there is a risk of harm to the public which would not be effectively managed by a caution order. In addition, public confidence in the profession and its regulation would not be maintained by the imposition of a caution order. For these reasons the Panel concluded that a caution order would not be appropriate.
60. The Panel went on to consider a conditions of practice order and had regard to paragraphs 152-166 of the Sanctions Policy.
61. The Panel was mindful that the Registrant had still not demonstrated insight or remediated. The Panel took note of paragraph 154 of the Sanctions Policy which states:-
‘Conditions will only be effective in cases where the registrant is genuinely committed to resolving the concerns raised and the panel is confident they will do so. Therefore, conditions of practice are unlikely to be suitable in cases in which the registrant has failed to engage with the fitness to practise process or where there are serious or persistent concerns’.
62. The Panel concluded that conditions of practice would not be appropriate or proportionate as the Registrant had not engaged with the substantive hearing or review hearing and had not provided any evidence of her commitment to resolve the failings. Accordingly, there was no evidence before the Panel that the Registrant would comply with any conditions of practice it could formulate.
63. The Panel did not consider that conditions of practice would adequately protect the public.
64. The Panel next went on to consider a suspension order and referred itself to paragraphs 167-175 of the Sanctions Policy and noted paragraph 169 which states :
‘A suspension order is likely to be appropriate where there are serious concerns which cannot be reasonably addressed by a conditions of practice order, but which do not require the registrant to be struck off the Register’.
65. The Sanctions Policy outlines that a suspension order is likely to be appropriate where:-
• ‘the registrant has insight;
• the issues are unlikely to be repeated; and
• there is evidence to suggest the registrant is likely to be able to resolve or remedy their failings…’.
66. The Panel considered the HCPC invitation to impose a further suspension order for a period of 6 months to give her a further opportunity to engage. However, it noted that the Registrant had been continually suspended from practice for a period of over 18 months since the substantive hearing had concluded, and it had no evidence of insight, or any evidence that the Registrant had started to remediate to mitigate the risk of repetition. The Panel concluded that the Registrant was unwilling or unable to resolve or remedy their failings and the risk of repetition remains, indeed, on the evidence available the Registrant seems to be in denial of the proven Allegation.
67. The Panel considered that the Registrant had failed to make any progress in acknowledging and remediating her failings since these concerns arose in 2022, she had failed to engage in the regulatory process, and despite being given guidance on the types of things she could undertake to remediate, she had failed to do so.
68. The Panel concluded that there would be no useful purpose in imposing a further suspension order when the Registrant had not engaged, had made no progress in demonstrating insight, and had shown hostility towards the HCPC’s attempts to engage her in the review process. The Panel considered that the Registrant was in denial, and that it was highly unlikely that the Registrant would engage during a further period of suspension, to the extent where her fitness to practise would be found to be no longer impaired.
69. The Panel went on to consider a striking off order which removes a Registrant’s name from the Register and prohibits the Registrant from practising in their profession. Whilst the Registrant was not present, the Panel noted that she had been made aware that striking off was an option from the Notice of Hearing served on her on 17 August 2026.
70. Paragraph 179 of the Sanctions Policy states ‘A striking off order will be appropriate for serious, persistent, deliberate or reckless acts which may include… failure to raise concerns, failure to work in partnership, abuse of professional position… involving a vulnerable person.’
71. The Panel also noted paragraph 180 which states:-
‘A striking off order is likely to be appropriate, whether or not the conduct is included in the examples of such conduct in the list above, where the nature and gravity of the concerns are such that any lesser sanction would be insufficient to protect the public, public confidence in the profession, and public confidence in the regulatory process. Some examples of such conduct include (this list is not exhaustive), where the registrant:
• lacks insight;
• continues to repeat the misconduct or, where a registrant has been suspended for two years continuously, fails to address a lack of competence (for example, due to not attempting to engage with any remediation); or
• is unwilling to resolve matters’.
72. The Panel found the conduct to be serious, and it had no evidence that the Registrant had insight into her actions or was willing to resolve matters. Accordingly, there remains a high risk of repetition.
73. The Panel found that the matter found proved was serious in nature and involved a vulnerable service user. The Registrant had failed to demonstrate insight or acknowledge the impact of her actions on the service user and their family. The Allegation had the potential to cause serious harm, the Panel considered that no lesser sanction than a striking off order was sufficient to protect the public and the wider public interest.
74. In making this decision, the Panel was aware that it has to act proportionately. The Panel considered the impact of the striking off order on the Registrant and was of the view that the public protection and public interest considerations outweigh the Registrant’s own interests. Further, the Panel was satisfied that a striking off order enables public confidence in the profession and its regulation to be maintained.
75. The striking off order is both necessary and proportionate to protect members of the public from the risk of harm that the Registrant poses, and to meet the public interest in maintaining confidence both in the profession and the HCPC. The Panel considered that any lesser sanction was insufficient to mark the seriousness of the concern, and to uphold public confidence in the profession and its regulator.
Order
ORDER: That the Registrar is directed to strike the name of Mrs Margaret Ellis from the Register on the date this Order comes into effect.
Notes
The Order imposed today will apply from 18 December 2026.
Right of Appeal
You may appeal to the High Court in England and Wales against the Panel’s decision and the order it has made against you.
Under Articles 30(10) and 38 of the Health Professions Order 2001, any appeal must be made to the court not more than 28 days after the date when this notice is served on you.
Hearing History
History of Hearings for Margaret Ellis
| Date | Panel | Hearing type | Outcomes / Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11/11/2026 | Conduct and Competence Committee | Review Hearing | Struck off |
| 28/04/2025 | Conduct and Competence Committee | Final Hearing | Suspended |