Andy Wells

Profession: Hearing aid dispenser

Registration Number: HAD03743

Hearing Type: Final Hearing

Date and Time of hearing: 10:00 28/10/2026 End: 17:00 30/10/2026

Location: Virtual via video conference

Panel: Conduct and Competence Committee
Outcome: Suspended

Please note that the decision can take up to 5 working days to be uploaded onto the HCPTS website. Please contact one of our Hearings Team Managers via tsteam@hcpts-uk.org or +44 (0)808 164 3084 if you require any further information.

Allegation

As a registered Hearing aid dispenser (HAD03743): 

1. On 24 July 2023, you misused customer data by contacting 947 Action for Deafness (AFD) patients to offer services for private ear wax removal from your new company.

2. On 18 September 2024, you were convicted at the Crawley magistrates’ court for knowingly and/or recklessly retaining personal data without consent of the controller. 

3. Your conduct at particular 1 above was dishonest, in that you; 

a. Knew that you did not have authorisation to use the data; and/or 
b. Sought to financially benefit from your misuse of service user data.

4. The matters set out in particulars 1 and 3 above constitute misconduct. 

5. By reason of the matters set out above, your fitness to practise is impaired by reason of misconduct and/or Conviction. 

Finding

Background:

1.    The Registrant was employed as a Hearing Aid Dispenser by Action for Deafness (‘AFD’) until June 2023 and was thereafter self-employed under his company name Sussex Hearing Care (‘SHC’).

2.    On 24 July 2023 the Registrant sent an email to 947 AFD patients offering services provided by SHC. 

3.    Following a police investigation, the Registrant was convicted in relation to using personal data (patient email addresses) for his financial benefit and without permission.  He was convicted at Crawley Magistrates’ Court on 18 September 2024 of knowingly / recklessly retaining personal data without the consent of the controller, and he was ordered to pay a fine of £400, costs and a victim surcharge.

4.    The Registrant has signed a formal agreed statement of facts in which he makes full and unequivocal admissions to the factual Particulars at 1, 2, 3 a) and 3 b) including admitting dishonesty as alleged. 

5.    The HCPC invited the Panel to find Particulars 1, 2, 3 a) and 3 b) proved by virtue of those admissions.

Decision on Facts:

6.    The Registrant admitted the factual particulars. The Panel accepted legal advice from the Legal Assessor as to the admissions made by the Registrant, and he referred to the HCPTS Practice Note on Admissions. The Panel should be satisfied that the admissions are clearly and unequivocally made and the Registrant understood.  

7.    The Panel had before it the agreement as to facts signed by the Registrant. It was satisfied that the Registrant properly understood the meaning and impact of his admissions to allegations 1, 2 and 3 a) and 3 (b) and it therefore found those allegations proved by way of admission. 

Grounds - Misconduct & Conviction:

8.    Having decided on the facts the Panel next heard evidence from JS who provided to the Panel a personal impact statement. 

9.    Before hearing that evidence, Ms Bass explained that the issue arising was not one of facts but concerned the context of the conduct, its seriousness, and the risks possibly created by the admitted, proved conduct. As to the ground of conviction, that ground was conclusively established by the certified copy of the conviction provided to the Panel.

10.    Ms Bass submitted that the Panel would have to consider whether the facts admitted and found proved amount to misconduct.  That should include consideration of the seriousness of the conduct and Ms Bass made reference to the relevant case law in the regard, including Roylance v GMC (no 2) [2000] 1 AC 311. Ms Bass also referred to the HCPC Standards of conduct, performance and ethics (2016) and to the HCPC Practice Note ‘Fitness to Practise Impairment’, which includes reference to the case law on misconduct.  She invited the Panel to consider the factors listed in paragraph 15 of that practice note, and submitted that the Panel should consider the level of culpability of the Registrant for any harm caused. 

11.    Ms Bass submitted that although the Registrant denies pre-planning and taking the email data deliberately, he admits knowing he did not have authorisation to use the data and that he sought financial gain.  Ms Bass submitted that this was contextual evidence only as to impact and culpability, but it may go to the question of seriousness of the conduct.  

12.    Ms Bass submitted that local residents were contacted, suggesting pre-planning, and the police investigation showed that a memory stick was inserted into AFD’s computer prior to him leaving their employ and that may indicate a deliberate course of action by the Registrant. 

Evidence of JS

13.    JS affirmed and adopted her formal witness statement as her evidence. She was the CEO of AFD at the relevant time, and she told the Panel about the Registrant’s employment and his departure from AFD. She explained the steps taken to report the data breach which occurred on 24 July 2023 and AFD’s response to the Information Commissioner.  The police also became involved. 

14.    JS told the Panel that the data breach had first been raised by a patient of AFD and that in total five patient complaints were received about the data breach.  JS said that the Registrant had provided his devices for examination by the police and that she had also conducted an investigation within AFD. 

15.    JS said that AFD operated across Sussex, and that the patient data the Registrant took all seemed to relate to patients near his home. She said that it therefore did not seem to her to be likely that the data had been extracted by the Registrant by accident. The police investigation resulted in the prosecution of the Registrant. The ICO also investigated the reported breach and AFD was not fined.  

16.    JS stated that all staff members were only allowed to email patients from AFD’s email address, and were not allowed to email patients on their personal email, and all were fully aware that they should never take patient data off the system. This was contained in the AFD Organisation Handbook. 

17.    JS also provided an impact statement detailing the impact of the data breach on her, on AFD staff and on the business as a whole.  She stated that AFD, a charity, ceased business on 30 September 2025. 

18.    The Registrant cross examined JS. He asked her about the emails between them at AFD around building a database of patients. She did not recall discussions between them and other staff about building a database that would use patient data such as emails.  She confirmed that the Registrant had provided to her all of the patient email addresses and had cooperated.  She agreed that she had asked him to wipe all details from his own devices, and he had done so. 

19.    In response to Panel questions, JS told the Panel about the impact on AFD. She said “it was horrendous” and took the focus off what they existed for. She said that the volume of work and reputational risk was considerable and that staff morale was “appalling.”  She said it had not in fact impacted too badly on their reputation, and the new Chief Operating Officer had dealt with it, but had been “catastrophic” and the business had now gone. She said the data breach may have played a part in the business shutting down, but she could not speculate. 

20.    As regards patients, JS said that AFD had to write to all 947 patients to explain the data breach, to reassure them and then explain the outcome.  Some patients also gave statements to the police. 

The Registrant’s Evidence on misconduct 

21.    The Registrant affirmed and said he had sent an unsolicited email to 947 patients of his former employer, AFD. He said he has not intended to cause any harm to them or to his former employer, and that he had no malicious intent but had identified the data by chance on his computer. He said he should have deleted it and told AFD at that point.  Instead, he sent a single email to each patient advertising his services. He said received some replies and he had told them that he should not have sent the email. When he realised his error he said he told the CEO of AFD and referred himself to the HCPC.

22.    The Registrant said it had been an error of judgment and it was isolated. A number of his former colleagues have provided positive references for him and he had never intended to cause any harm to AFD or patients. He said he has fully complied with the investigations by AFD, the police and the HCPC.  He said he could not apologise enough and he had agreed to cover some of AFD’s costs for the work on the data breach, repaying a total of £30,000.  

23.    The Registrant said he was now registered with the ICO and had completed CPD on data protection and also completed an ICO course on data protection, which had 8-12 modules and an examination.  He had also completed other courses on data protection and GDPR.  He said he now keeps a minimum of data and it is only shared with consent. He said he password protects his work and uses a privacy screen and he has ensured that he upholds HCPC standards. 

24.    The Registrant said that he understood this was serious but it had been “silly” but was isolated. He said he was not aware of the location of patients he sent the emails to, and he had always been open and cooperated with AFD.  He told the Panel that he had, whilst at AFD, discussed at several meetings the creating of a database of patient email addresses, and he had later assisted AFD to provide instructions on the recovery of data.

25.    The Registrant said that he had never left a USB stick in a computer, but said that he did use one on most work days at AFD.  He said that on his last day his computer had been removed and his access removed.  He had removed the USB stick on that last day, a Friday, after the computer had been turned off and said that it may have been that the operating system did not register the unplugging event until switched back on the next Monday. He said he had not left the USB in over that weekend. 

26.    The Registrant said that he had briefly used his own laptop at one point, as a colleague had a problem with his laptop and so the Registrant had given his work laptop to that colleague for that day. It had taken some time to have the laptop replaced and in that period he had used his personal laptop, and would have used a USB to transfer data so that he could work at home. He said that at one time AFD had 12 locations and so he frequently used a USB stick and colleagues laptops.

27.    The Registrant said he had never sought to solicit AFD patients whilst he was working there, and he continued to have a good relationship with former AFD colleagues. He said he took full responsibility for his actions, and that what he did fell well below HCPC Standards. He said he had tried to make amends and to atone.  He said he gravely regretted what he had done and he had learned from his “awful error of judgment”. 

28.    In response to  Ms Bass, the Registrant said that he helped to create “crystal” reports to assist AFD at the time, subject to pre-approval by JS. He said he would use compile these reports, along with a colleague, and then email out to patients where needed.  He said he was experienced in excel and using in it to send out emails. He accepted in principle that one might see that as being what he had deliberately done in the data breach, but it was not what he had done. 

29.    The Registrant said that he accepted that patient details would likely have been on the USB stick he used.  He said he had sent an email to all the patients he had email addresses for, and that may not have been limited to AFD patients. He did not accept that he had only sent emails to patients near to his home. He said he used the emails he had on the USB stick by chance, and that if he had targeted patients he could easily have covered his tracks by not providing all the information and cooperation he had to the AFD investigation. 

30.    As regards the email that the Registrant sent to the patients, he explained that he had mentioned AFD as a former employer to give him credibility. He accepted that he could see now that he had used AFD’s good name to build his own business, but that had not been his intention. 

31.    As regards the impact, the Registrant did not disagree with what JS had said in her evidence. He said that he felt “terrible” about what he had done, and it was “stupidity” and that he had been “excited” about his new business, but he had not intended to cause any harm to AFD or their patients. He said he had worked hard for AFD, their CEO and employees, and he accepted, with hindsight, that harm was a foreseeable result of his actions.  

Submissions on Grounds – Misconduct 

32.    Ms Bass submitted that the Registrant has breached the following standards in the HCPC’s Standards of Conduct, Performance, and Ethics (2016):

1.    Promote and protect the interests of service users and carers 

Treat service users and carers with respect

1.1   You must treat service users and carers as individuals, respecting their privacy and dignity

5.    Respect confidentiality 
  
Using information 

5.1  You must treat information about service users as confidential.
  
Disclosing information 

5.2  You must only disclose confidential information if:

 – you have permission;
 – the law allows this;
 – it is in the service user’s best interests; or
 – it is in the public interest, such as if it is necessary to protect public safety or prevent harm to other people.

 9.  Be honest and trustworthy 

Personal and professional behaviour

9.1  You must make sure that your conduct justifies the public’s trust and confidence in you and your profession.

33.    Ms Bass submitted that the Registrant had misused patient data and that it was done dishonestly. In addition, she submitted that the dishonesty was pre-planned before he left AFD.  She submitted that he had intended to use and misuse patient data and that increases the seriousness of the conduct. 

34.    Ms Bass submitted that the Panel ought to be cautious about the pre-planning aspect of the dishonesty and only come to that view if it was satisfied as to the evidence in that regard. She referred to factors a) to h) in paragraph 15 of the HCPC Practice Note “Fitness to Practise Impairment” as follows:-

a.    the extent of the departure from expected professional conduct and standards

b.    The extent of the impact on maintaining public confidence in the profession

c.    the risk of harm to patients, service users, colleagues and the public, irrespective of the actual harm caused

d.    the effect of the conduct or failings on the delivery of care and safe practice

e.    whether the conduct or failings were repeated or isolated

f.    whether the conduct was directed at or involved vulnerable service users

g.    whether the Registrant abused their professional position

h.    whether the conduct involved any dishonest, sexual misconduct or predatory behaviour….

35.    Ms Bass submitted that these factors were all engaged, making the conduct particularly serious and that the conduct fell far below the standards expected of a professional. She accepted the conduct may be isolated but the Panel was invited to find this was pre-planned conduct and that it was an abuse of his professional position.

36.    Ms Bass invited the Panel to find the conduct was serious and amounted to misconduct.

Legal advice 

37.    The Legal Assessor referred the Panel to the HCPC guidance on misconduct and to the relevant case law including Roylance v GMC (no 2) [2000] 1 AC 311. He stressed the need to carefully consider seriousness and to keep in focus the conduct found proved. He advised the Panel to be cautious about the evidence it has heard which was contextual only to the question of seriousness and which could not form the basis for any further findings of fact at this stage in the hearing. 

Decision on Grounds:

38.    The Panel accepted the legal advice.  It found the ground of conviction in respect of allegation 2 given the certificate of conviction.  It was mindful of the allegations, the admissions and the conduct found proved and that misconduct is a matter for the Panel’s professional judgement.

39.    The Panel considered allegations 1 and 3. It considered that the data breach will have caused real concern amongst the 947 patients who received the email from the Registrant followed by the confirmation that there had been a data breach. Further, the conduct involved the dishonest misuse of patient data, the emails, and was for the Registrant’s financial gain. He therefore placed his interests before those of his patients and AFD. The Registrant accepted in his evidence that he had a good working knowledge of the patient details and of producing report and spreadsheets. The Panel was of the view that the conduct was not likely to have been accidental, particularly since it was admittedly done for the Registrant’s financial gain. 

40.    The Panel found that the conduct in Allegations 1 and 3, whether considered separately or together, fell far short of what would have been proper in the circumstances.  Given the dishonesty involved and the impact on patients, AFD and the profession, which the Registrant did not dispute, the Panel found that the conduct was certainly serious and would also be considered deplorable. 

41.    The Panel agreed with the HCPC submissions that the conduct was a breach of HCPC Standards of Conduct, Performance, and Ethics (2016), Standards 1, 5 and 9.  The Panel concluded that the conduct at allegation was serious and that it amounted to misconduct. 

HCPC Submissions on impairment  

42.    Ms Bass for the HCPC referred the Panel to the HCPC Practice Note ‘Fitness to Practise Impairment’ and she reminded the Panel that it should consider today whether the Registrant’s fitness to practise is impaired.  She referred to the relevant case and the tests set out in CHRE v NMC and Grant [2011] EWHC 927 (Admin). She submitted that the Registrant has used patient data and caused upset and created difficulties for AFD. Acting dishonestly breached a fundamental tenet of the profession, and the misuse of the data was an abuse of his position. 

43.    Ms Bass also referred to the public interest issues and she submitted that the Panel will need to consider whether there is a risk of repetition. The Registrant has cooperated and has never denied he had the data, and he has admitted the allegation in full. He has undertaken training.  However, she submitted that very poor decisions were made by the Registrant and his attitude to the needs of patients suggests a deep-seated attitudinal problem. 

44.    Ms Bass submitted that a risk of repetition does remain and, given the nature of the allegation, public confidence in the profession would be undermined if there was no finding of current impairment. She submitted that a finding of impairment of fitness to practise was therefore required on both personal and public grounds. 

The Registrant’s Submissions on impairment 

45.    The Registrant apologised for his conduct and he fully accepted the Panel decision and his dishonesty.  He said he was fully aware of the impact on the public and the profession.  He said his conduct was deplorable and fell far below professional standards and his own.  He said he had never intended to cause any harm. He said he has tried to reflect exemplary standards and he has many 5 star reviews in this current professional practice. 

46.    The Registrant said that he had registered with the ICO and he had attended and paid for a data protection course and that he now better understood the impact of his misuse on patients and the profession.  He now takes care with data and ensures consent and permission.

47.    The Registrant said he had shown remorse and apologised. He said he has never denied using the information and that he fully cooperated with all the investigations.  He said that he had strived to be a better person and his dishonesty was not fitting and it was the worst thing that he had ever done.  He made an unreserved apology to his patients, AFD, the profession and the HCPC. 

Decision on Impairment:

48.    The Legal Assessor reminded the Panel of the HCPC guidance in the Practice Note on ‘Fitness to Practise Impairment’.  He also referred to the relevant case law, including CHRE v NMC and Grant [2011] EWHC 927 (admin) and stressed the importance of considering the Registrant’s insight and remediation of his practice. He advised the Panel this matter was one for its own professional judgement and that there was no burden of proof and that the issue to consider was the Registrant’s current fitness to practise. 

49.    The Panel was mindful of the guidance and the approach to assessing fitness to practise as expressed in the four limbs set out in the Grant case as follows:-

“Do the findings show that fitness to practise is impaired in the sense that:
a)    Has the Registrant in the past acted and/or is liable in the future to act in a way so as to put service users at unwarranted risk of harm;
b)    Has the Registrant in the past brought and/or is liable in the future to bring the profession into disrepute;
c)    Has the Registrant in the past breached and/or is liable in the future to breach one of the fundamental tenets of the profession?
d) has in the past acted dishonestly and/or is liable to act dishonestly in the future.”

50.    The Panel considered the misconduct was remediable and acknowledged that dishonesty can be difficult to remediate. It next considered whether the Registrant had sufficiently remediated and demonstrated insight.

51.    On the personal element of impairment, the Panel considered the misconduct and the dishonesty and the risk of repetition. The Panel found that the Registrant has admitted the facts, demonstrated genuine remorse and he has made a clear and unequivocal apology. 

52.    The Panel found that he was a senior member of staff at AFD, a Charity, and he had clear responsibilities to act with integrity and honesty.  He did not do so despite, it appears, knowing that what he did was wrong.  He has since taken steps around training on data protection and he has completed relevant courses in that area to remediate his practice. 

53.    However, the Panel did not have before it sufficient evidence of remediation on the important issues of honesty, ethics and integrity. The misconduct indicates an attitudinal issue and the Panel was not sufficiently reassured that the Registrant has fully reflected and understood why he behaved in the way that he did.  He dishonestly used the data for his own financial gain and he breached a fundamental tenet of the profession, namely honesty. He caused unwarranted harm to patients who will have been concerned, worried and stressed when they were advised of the data breach.

54.    The Panel was of the view that the Registrant has sufficiently addressed the data management and technical aspects of the data misuse misconduct, and he has demonstrated good insight into those technical and operational elements of data use and misuse. 

55.    What continued to concern the Panel was a lack of sufficiently developed reflection and insight by the Registrant into the ethical and attitudinal aspects of his misconduct, his dishonesty and, indeed, his criminal conviction. 

56.    The Panel concluded that there continues to be a risk of repetition of the dishonest conduct and it was unable to conclude that it was highly unlikely that the Registrant would not repeat that behaviour. 

57.    As such the Panel decided that the Registrant’s fitness to practise is currently impaired on the personal element. 

58.    The Panel considered that the misconduct does bring the profession in to disrepute.  The dishonesty is serious and it had a significant impact on patients, AFD, colleagues and the profession.  The misconduct is of such gravity, and coupled with the conviction, that not to find the Registrant’s fitness to practise currently impaired would undermine public confidence in the profession and in the regulator.  The public would be most concerned given the nature and gravity of this dishonesty, and the Panel therefore decided that a finding of current impairment was required in the circumstances of this case and is necessary to declare and uphold proper professional standards. 

59.    The Panel therefore found the Registrant’s current fitness to practise is impaired on both the personal and the public elements. 

HCPC Submissions on Sanction

60.    Ms Bass referred the Panel to the HCPC guidance on sanction. She submitted that the Panel should consider the guidance and consider such as risk, deterrence and public confidence.  She submitted that the aggravating features may be that this was a deliberate act of dishonesty and an abuse of a position of trust. She submitted that the mitigating features may be the Registrant’s repayment of AFD expenses, consistent expressions of remorse and evidence of some remediation and developing insight. 

61.    Ms Bass submitted that the sanctions should be considered in ascending order. She invited the Panel to consider the Sanctions guidance, including paragraphs 131 - 134 on conviction. A sanction must be just and proportionate. She also referred to the guidance at paragraphs 87 -89 and 179 on dishonesty.  She submitted that she was not suggesting that Striking Off was a necessary sanction in all cases of dishonesty.  

Registrant’s Submissions on Sanction

62.    The Registrant said that he fully accepted and acknowledges the decisions made by the Panel and the impact his dishonesty has had.  It was a single act and since then he said he had cooperated and been fully compliant with all the investigations and with this process. He had previously been of good character, and he said he accepted that his dishonesty was deliberate and that he had harmed patients and the business, AFD. He was willing to undergo any steps he was required to take to remediate. 

63.    [Redacted].

64.    The Registrant said he was striving to be a better person and a better role model to his profession and to his daughters. 

Decision on Sanction:

65.    The Panel heard legal advice from the Legal Assessor who referred it to the HCPC Sanctions Policy.  He reminded it to act proportionately and to impose the least restrictive sanction that protects the public and the wider public interest. It must balance the interests of the Registrant with the need to protect the public. 

66.    The Panel accepted the legal advice and considered the HCPC Sanctions guidance.  It first looked at mitigating and aggravating features. It found the following mitigation:-

•    A single isolated incident, albeit serious 
•    Early and full admissions
•    Developing insight 
•    Full acceptance of impact and seriousness
•    Full acceptance of the Panel’s findings 
•    Previous good character supported by testimonials 
•    No evidence of repetition since the allegation
•    Positive remediation of some aspects of the misconduct
•    No clinical concerns 
•    Genuine remorse and apologies
•    Repayment of costs to AFD
 
67.    The Panel found the following aggravating factors:-

•    An impact on many vulnerable patients
•    Deliberate dishonesty
•    Abuse of professional position

68.    The Panel took account that the Registrant has been convicted, and to some extent the public interest has already been met.  He has received a sentence for the offence, and he has been punished by the Courts. 

69.    The Panel found that the mitigation in this case was powerful. The Panel was mindful of the Sanctions Policy, including paragraphs 54 – 58 on insight; 72 -74 on breach of trust; 87- 89 on dishonesty and 130 – 134 on convictions. It balanced the Registrant’s interests with the need to protect the public and the wider public interest and be proportionate. 

70.    The Panel considered that this case is too serious to take no action or to impose a Caution.  It was mindful of paragraphs 147 which states:-

•    A caution order is likely to be an appropriate sanction for cases in which:
•    the issue is isolated, limited, or relatively minor in nature;
•    there is a low risk of repetition;
•    the registrant has shown good insight; and
•    the registrant has undertaken appropriate remediation.

71.    This case is not relatively minor as it involves dishonesty and a Caution order would fail to reflect the seriousness of the findings and would fail to protect the public, uphold proper professional standards or act as a deterrent. 

72.    The Panel next considered whether to impose conditions of practice on the Registrant. It considered paragraph 153 of the Sanctions Policy:-

“A conditions of practice order is likely to be appropriate in cases where:

•    the registrant has insight;

•    the concerns are capable of being remedied or managed;

•    there are no persistent or general concerns which would prevent the registrant from remediating;

•    appropriate, proportionate, realistic and verifiable conditions can be formulated;

•    the panel is confident the registrant will comply with the conditions;

•    a reviewing panel will be able to determine whether or not those conditions have or are being met; and

•    a panel is satisfied that a registrant may continue to practise with conditions without exposing the public to risk of harm.”

73.    The Registrant has developing insight and the outstanding concerns as to honesty are capable of being remedied. There are no persistent or general concerns, this is not a competency case and there is no evidence of repetition, albeit a risk has been identified. Having heard from the Registrant, the Panel was confident that the Registrant is willing and able to learn, to remediate and to comply with conditions.  

74.    However, with paragraph 156 in mind, the Panel has found the misconduct was serious and the dishonesty could not be described as minor. The Panel concluded that a Conditions of Practice Order would not reflect the nature and gravity of the misconduct and would not serve to maintain public confidence in the profession. 

75.    The Panel next considered Suspension and paragraphs 167- 170 of the Sanctions Policy. The Registrant has insight and he has already taken real steps to remedy his practice.  His conduct was isolated, he has fully acknowledged and admitted his dishonesty and he has shown genuine remorse and a positive willingness to learn, improve and remediate. 

76.    The Registrant is self-employed and he has worked without any further incident for some three years since this incident.  He has patients and his professional contribution to his community is real and is not unimportant or irrelevant.  [Redacted]. 

77.    However, the dishonesty is serious and is at the higher end of the spectrum of dishonesty, but it was not repeated or persistent. Further, the Registrant has demonstrated that he has developing insight and that he is on the path to full remediation.  

78.    In all these circumstances, the Panel concluded that a Suspension Order for three months would sufficiently mark the seriousness of the case whilst not being disproportionate or punitive. That period may assist the Registrant in further developing his insight into his deliberate dishonesty. The Panel decided that this 3 month Suspension Order was just, proportionate and necessary, and that it sends an appropriate and clear message to both the profession and the public. 

79.    The Registrant has fully engaged since referring himself to the HCPC and he has shown developing insight and remediation.  His conduct is not fundamentally incompatible with remaining on the Register. Striking Off would in the circumstances of this case go further than is required to mark the seriousness of the case and to protect the public. It would be punitive. 

80.    The Panel imposed a 3 month Suspension Order. It was of the view that a future reviewing Panel would likely be assisted by the Registrant providing a detailed, written reflective piece on the impact of his dishonesty on the profession and the public, including reflection and insight into his deliberate dishonesty. 

Order

The Registrar is directed to suspend the registration of Andy Wells for a period of 3 months, from the date this Order comes into effect.

Notes

Interim Order: 

Application

81.    In light of its findings on Sanction, the Panel next considered an application by Ms Bass for an Interim Suspension Order for 18 months to cover the appeal period before the Sanction becomes operative. She submitted that it would be inconsistent not to apply an interim order given the sanction imposed.  She submitted an Interim Suspension Order was necessary to protect the public and in the public interest.  

82.    The Panel heard from the Registrant who said he did not intend to appeal.  He said that he did not want an interim suspension order imposed so that he can make arrangements with his patients for appropriate care. If he did not do so, that may result in extra expenses for patients,  and he also required time to make financial arrangements to cover the suspension period. 

Decision 

83.    The Panel accepted the advice of the Legal Assessor who referred it to the HCPTS Practice Note on Interim Orders.  He reminded the Panel that an Interim Order must be necessary to protect the public, or be otherwise in the public interest. The Panel must act proportionately and balance the interests of the Registrant with the need to protect the public.

84.    The Panel was mindful of its earlier findings and concluded that an Interim Order is necessary to protect the public during the appeal period. It was mindful of the issues raised by the Registrant, but this is outweighed by the need to protect the public. 

85.    The Panel decided that that it would be wholly incompatible with its earlier findings, and with the Suspension Order imposed, to conclude that an Interim Suspension is not in the meantime necessary for the protection of the public or otherwise in the public interest. 

86.    Accordingly, the Panel concluded that an Interim Suspension Order should be imposed on both public protection and public interest grounds. It decided that it is appropriate for that Interim Order to be imposed for a period of 18 months to cover the appeal period.  When the appeal period expires, this Interim Order will come to an end unless there has been an application to appeal.  If there is no appeal, the Suspension Order shall apply when the appeal period expires.

Interim Suspension Order:

The Panel makes an Interim Suspension Order under Article 31(2) of the Health Professions Order 2001, the same being necessary to protect members of the public and being otherwise in the public interest.  

This order will expire: (if no appeal is made against the Panel’s decision and Order) upon the expiry of the period during which such an appeal could be made; (if an appeal is made against the Panel’s decision and Order) the final determination of that appeal, subject to a maximum period of 18 months.

Hearing History

History of Hearings for Andy Wells

Date Panel Hearing type Outcomes / Status
28/10/2026 Conduct and Competence Committee Final Hearing Suspended